“She smelled like trees. In the courner it was dark, but I could see the window. I squatted there, holding the slipper. I couldn’t see it, but my hands saw it, and I could hear it getting night, and my hands saw the slipper but I couldn’t see myself, but my hands could see the slipper, and I squatted there, hearing it getting dark.” (Page 72).
In this passage Benjy is having a flashback. This passage isvery annoying due to the repetativeness and the utter fact that it doesn’t make sense with what Benjy was talking about before.
Benjy states multiple times throughout his chapter that “she smelled like trees”. She meaning Caddy. For some reason Benjy is obsessed with one time that Caddy got up and climbed a tree with dirty underwear. He obsesses over it, and brings it up multiple times in his chapter. It doesn’t really seem like an important thing for a person so dwell on.
Benjy keeps saying how he coudln’t see the slipper he was holding, but his hands could see it. Hands, don’t see, hands feel. Benjy just keeps on restating that he can’t see anything, but his hands can see it. I think that might have something to do with his handicap. Or possibly since it was dark, he felt it alot and became famililar enough with it, that he could see it in his mind even if he didn’t have to use his eyes. Another thing he says is he could hear it getting night. Peopl don’t normally phrase recognizing that it’s night time with the word hear. I think that that shows the Benjy is more observant then he is thought to be. Because he could hear it getting night, he could hear the certain bugs that chirp, or certain noises from the street that only come at night. I think although Benjy has a handicap, he is quite observant to his surrounddings.
February 12, 2007 at 4:56 am
I like the passage you picked a lot and how you explained it, especially because I had no idea what was going on there. I really liked how you talked about the way Benjy constantly refers to Caddy smelling like trees, because I think that’s really important. I think its kind of an important link to the past relationship he had with Caddy, and eventually a vital way for him to try to let her go.
February 15, 2007 at 4:13 pm
I agree that Benjy is alot more observant than he is thought to be. I like that you picked a passage about Benjy that gives a lot of detail to his character. It shows his obsession with Caddy, the fact that he can’t rid himself of memories, or he gets obsessed with them as well it also shows that he is quite observant of his surroundings which you don’t exactly get from some passages in the book.
February 16, 2007 at 3:37 am
I really liked this passage. As Benjy being the first out of the brothers for us, as the readers, to get to know, we first had the opportunity to see the weird family relationship each and every one of the brothers has with their sister, Caddy. As Benjy being disabled, he is very attached to Caddy who cares for him. He obsesses a great deal about Caddy smelling like trees, which in my opinion, he drags out too much. Although he is handicaped, I too feel he is very observant about his surroundings even though all his memories he recalls, are difficult to put in order.